Four people were killed in a small California resort town, including Sue Sharp, her son John, daughter Tina, and John's friend Dana. This may be the reason the Department of Justice in Sacramento stepped into the Keddie case early. They also found a bloody fingerprint on the handrail leading down from the back door. ABC10's Madison Wade spoke with. Following his arrest in 1996, police looked at the . Although the therapist alerted authorities, nothing was reportedly done. He admitted that he had a problem with his temper, and Marilyn had claimed that he tried to run her and her son over. Geography [ edit] According to the United States Census Bureau, the CDP has a total area of 0.6 square miles (1.6 km 2 ), all of it land. Were continuing with the investigation, and were doing interviews, and we have several persons of interest. Richard (along with Mike Hamilton) is the person who spread the rumor around school (reported by Joey C) that Martin and Boubede killed Sue and the boys and "took" Tina. [15], Sue was discovered lying on her side near the living room sofa, nude from the waist down[19] and gagged with a blue bandana and her own underwear, which had been secured with tape. This might explain why the Sacramento DOJ sent two allegedly corrupt organized crime special agents instead of agents from the homicide department. However, none of the evidence helped the investigators find the killers or determine how she died. Justin recalled that both men wore glasses and that the two older boys, John and Dana, came home while Sue was talking to the men. Around a month after the Keddie murders took place, the neighborhood friend, Justin, who was one of the survivors, told his therapist that he was having dreams about the murder. A bent steak knife was on the floor. It's been forty years since the Kebbie Cabin Murders happened in a rural area of Plumas County. Immediately, the two lead suspects were Justin Smartts father and the Sharps neighbors, Martin Smartt and his houseguest, ex-convict John Bo Boudebe who was known to have connections to organized crime in the area. Sheila Sharp who discovered the victims of the Keddie Cabin 28 murders in 1981, when she was 14 hopes the cold case finally will be resolved By Jeff Truesdell Published on November 25, 2016. On the night of the Keddie cabin murders, Marilyn, Boubede (or Bo as they called him), and Marty had been out together at the local bar. Plumas County Sheriffs Department The Keddie family about four years before the murders. Young John was closest to the front door, face-up, his hands blood-covered and bound with medical tape. [24] About 4,000 man-hours were spent working the case,[24] which Thomas described as "frustrating". The bodies of Sue, John, and Dana were found on the morning of April 12 by Sue's 14-year-old daughter, Sheila, who had been sleeping at a friend's house. Marilyn moved out of Cabin 26 the day after the murders. Welcome! Gamberg also discovered a hunting knife in Keddie under some junk and sent that in for further analysis. A daughter was kidnapped and her remains were later found. First, they approached the site of Cabin 28, which at this point had been torn down. Unfortunately, they later went into foster care as their aunt already had several children and couldnt handle more. The victims were bound with electrical wire and medical tape. Additionally, some sources say that on the hypnosis tapes, the police made suggestions to Justin during the session. The back door left ajar. Authorities also interviewed Marty's close friend, John "Bo" Boubede, who lived with Marty and his wife, and was out with Marty on the night the murders occurred. The date was April 11, 1981, when Cabin 28 saw the horrors that crowd it and to this day, the case remains cold. He was placed under hypnosis in an attempt to recall any details of the night. Victims,. Although Justin's dreams, and the details he provided during hypnosis, were chilling, it is unclear whether he actually witnessed the murders or the dreams simply echoed details reported by the media. Cabin 28 and others in the small Keddie community were allowed to deteriorate in the years following the Keddie murders. Any case without an apparent motive is the toughest to solve, Stoy recalled to the Sacramento Bee in 1987. As reported by The Mystique, Justin began having vivid dreams in the days after the murders. Beyond the living room was the kitchen and two bedrooms. What else do you want? [17], The murders of Sue, John, and Dana were notably vicious:[13] two bloodied knives and one hammer were found at the scene,[15][18] and one of the knives (a steak knife later determined to have been used in the murders) had been bent at roughly 30 degrees. For 35 years, Sheila Sharp has tried to repress the memory of finding the brutally murdered bodies of her mother and older brother in her familys cabin home in the Sierra Nevada Mountains a crime that remains unsolved. Her friends dad retrieved the three unharmed boys through their bedroom window so they would not have to see the scene. However, though the three boys initially claimed to have slept through the massacre, Rickey and Gregs friend Justin Smartt did later say that he saw Sue with two men in the house that night. Sue and John had suffered similar types of wounds. It matched the description of the one Marty gave in his interrogation. Watch our new 10-part true crime show, People Magazine Investigates, which airs Mondays (9 p.m. The three youngsters were hanging out at the house since the afternoon. Blood was all over the victims, the floors, walls, ceiling, both bedroom doors, and on the railing of the outside stairs. About the Cabin 28 Keddie Murders Case: The morning of April 12, 1981, Glenna Sue Sharp and her kids, Tina and John, and John's friend, Dana Wingate, were brutally murdered inside house #28 in Keddie, California. Gamberg sent the tape to other law enforcement agencies for analysis and possible leads. Keddie Cabin 28 Murders Welcome David Craig McNarie! Blog. Neighbors said that for the most part, she kept to herself but the family was integrating well. At least one other person was killed that night: her teenage brother's friend, whose body also was found by then 14-year-old Sheila on the living room floor of Cabin 28 in Keddie, California, on. The murders tooks place in Cabin 28 of the Keddie Resort. Episode Info She also appreciated the fact that it was in a more rural, wooded setting. The bodies of Sue, John, and Dana were found on the morning of April 12 by Sue's 14-year-old daughter, Sheila, who had been sleeping at a friend's house. We sheltered them, she says about her brothers in the aftermath of the murders. 28 of the Keddie Resort. ET) on Investigation Discovery. Sue's two younger sons, Rick and Greg, as well as their friend Justin Smartt, were also in the house but were unharmed. The sheriff at the time of the murders, Doug Thomas, and his deputy. April 12, 1981, the bodies of 36-year-old Sue Sharp, her 15-year-old son John and his 17-year-old friend Dana Wingate were found in Cabin 28 at the Keddie Resort, north of Quincy. However, when this failed, the Keddie Resort owner Gary Mollath turned a series of cabins into low-income rental housing. It would be another three years after the Keddie murders that Tina was found. Working together the result was both fascinating and spooky. [6][10], Around 7:00 am[6][12] on the morning of April 12, Sheila returned to #28 and discovered the dead bodies of Sue, John, and Dana in the house's living room. Later, police learned that maybe not all the boys had actually been asleep. This was a couple years ago. Blood was everywhere. "[27] A grid pattern search of the area covering a 5-mile (8.0km) radius around the house was conducted with police canines, but the efforts were fruitless. Investigators were called about an hour after Sheila had discovered her slain family. It wasnt until three years later on April 22, 1984, when Ronald Pedrini reported that he was in the woods about 90 miles southwest of Keddie when he stumbled upon something suspicious. Forty years after the incident, the quadruple murder in the woods still baffles the nation. In 1981 in Cabin 28 of the Keddie Resort, California, three members of the Sharp family, as well as one of their family friends, were bludgeoned to death with hammers, with one repeatedly stabbed. It would also explain why the Smartt boy and the other Sharp boys in the adjoining room were spared. All victims had suffered blunt-force trauma by hammer or hammers. The oldest boy, John, and his buddy, Dana, had spent the day in Quincy. Composite sketch of the Keddie murder suspects. On April 11th, Sue's daughter, Sheila Sharp came home to find her family slain in their cabin. It has also been suggested that he was asked leading questions during hypnosis. Gamberg was a young deputy when the Keddie cabin murders occurred. How could murder with so much evidence remain unsolved? He lives in the West Midlands, UK with his wife and son. Plumas County Sheriffs DepartmentA back view of cabin 28 where the family had lived for a year. 28 of the Keddie Resort. Although the identity of the murderer is still a mystery, new information has surfaced in the last decade and could help to solve the Keddie cabin murders. Police were called to the scene at around 8:05 that morning, having been alerted by the Seabolt family . According to Historic Mysteries, Justin said Sue was talking to the men when John and Dana arrived home. All That's Interesting is a Brooklyn-based digital publisher that seeks out stories that illuminate the past, present, and future. Justin said he saw one of the men stab Sue Sharp. Clipping from Reno Gazette-Journal, April 13, 2016.DMAC. The children were attending school in Quincy and were making friends. Stabbed. To put it bluntly, dmac is a fabulist. In press releases accompanying the sketches, the suspects were described as being in their late 20s to early 30s; one stood between 5feet 11inches (1.80m) to 6feet 2inches (1.88m) tall with dark-blonde hair, and the other between 5feet 6inches (1.68m) and 5feet 10inches (1.78m) with black, greased hair. Gary Mollath, who owned one of the failed resorts, turned his cabins into long-term rental units for low-income families. At the centre of its hub was Keddie Resort, a collection of 33 rustic cabins which could be rented out long term for around $170 per month. Somehow, this erupted into a bout of violence between them, which resulted in the murders. KEDDIE (CBS13) Investigators believe they may have found one of the weapons used in a 35-year-old murder mystery. The murders took place in cabin 28, during the late evening of April 11, 1981 and/or early morning of the 12th. Historic Memories reports Keddie was once a bustling town with a busy railroad terminal. Both Gamberg and Hagwood said they believe authorities are getting closer to solving the case. Keddie is a census-designated place in Plumas County, California, United States. Further, the home did not indicate forced entry, though detectives did recover an unidentified fingerprint from a handrail on the back stairs. Despite his lies and inconsistencies in his stories, police cleared him as a suspect. [6] Sheila departed house #28 shortly after 8:00 pm to sleep over at the Seabolts, which she had never before done. The six of them: 36-year-old Sue, her 15-year-old son John, 14-year-old daughter Sheila, 12-year-old daughter Tina, and 10-year-old Rick and 5-year-old Greg, were friendly with their nearby neighbors at the Keddie resort. Deputy Hank Klement was the first to arrive on the scene and he reported blood everywhere on the walls, the bottoms of the victims shoes, Sues bare feet, the bedding in Tinas room, the furniture, the ceiling, the doors, and on the back steps. A fourth victim, a 12-year-old daughter, vanished in the night-her remains found years later and miles away. [19] John and Dana suffered blunt-force trauma to their heads caused by a hammer or hammers. Last post Re: Keddie RR murder by Copybot.2 Fri Apr 08, 2022 9:18 pm; 1990 - 1999. The Keddie victims were bound with tape and electrical cords. Afterward, she provided Plumas Country Sheriffs Dept. Later that year, a knife was recovered in a trashcan outside the Keddie General Store; authorities also believed this item to be linked to the crimes. Stranger still, in an adjoining bedroom the two youngest Sharp boys, Rickey and Greg, as well as their friend and neighbor, 12-year-old Justin Smartt were found unharmed. In a letter, Marty purportedly said: Ive paid the price of your love and now that Ive bought it with four peoples lives, you tell me we are through. Although the Sharps cabin did not indicate forced entry, detectives were able to recover an unidentified fingerprint from a handrail that led to the cabins back door. August 30 1984 Paradise Rapist. The Keddie Murders: A cold case suddenly getting warm. Did Genene Jones Kill As Many As 60 Children As A Pediatric Nurse? On the morning of April 11, 14-year-old Sheila Sharp stepped into Cabin 28 to a . The living room was in complete chaos, and Sue, John, and Johns friend, Dana, were dead on the floor. Published October 18, 2021 Updated November 1, 2021 Between April 11 and April 12, 1981, Glenna "Sue" Sharp and three others were brutally killed in the resort town of Keddie, California. Investigators theorized that someone might have interrupted the murders taking place before the culprits had a chance to kill the younger children in their bedrooms. Amid his interview with police, authorities learned Smartt and his wife were enrolled in a class with Sue. The Keddie Murders On the morning of April 11th, 1981, 14-year-old Sheila Sharp was returning from a neighbor's house following a sleepover. This is a site about the Keddie murders that happened the night of April 11-12, 1981 in Keddie, CA Sheilas sister, 12-year-old Tina Sharp, was nowhere to be found. [17] He later admitted to having briefly entered the home through the back door to see if anyone was still alive, potentially contaminating evidence in the process. Boubede told authorities he was a former Chicago police officer and that Marilyn was his niece, which were both later revealed to be untrue. In September 1980, Sharp found a larger home in the former resort town of Keddie, California. The Mystery Behind The Keddie Cabin Murders Explained. The discovery of Tinas remains raised even more questions than before. The two had only met weeks before the killings while Boubede was receiving treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder at the nearby Veterans Administration Hospital. Plumas County Sheriffs Office Cabin 28 at Keddie Resort, 1981. Nevertheless, Gamberg says that six people may have been involved. At least one other person was killed that night: her teenage brother's friend, whose body also was found by then 14-year-old Sheila on the living room floor of Cabin 28 in Keddie, California, on the morning of April 12, 1981. A Net Inceptions project. Joe Turner is a freelance writer of crime with a passion for unsolved mysteries. It was believed that Martin and Sue were having an affair and that Sue was supposedly counseling Marilyn to leave her husband, who she had said was abusive to her. In 1979, she left her abusive husband. The most widely accepted theory involves a love triangle between Martin, Marilyn, and Sue. The East Area Rapist used electrical cords to bind victims. Also, the murderers must have been aware of the three remaining boys in the cabin. In 1979, Glenna "Sue" Sharp left her abusive husband and moved herself and her five children from Connecticut to Quincy, California. When police interviewed the three young survivors who had been in the home all three said they had slept . All of their injuries happened after the killers tied them up. Blood patterns indicated that her legs were initially splayed apart, but someone moved her and covered her body with a yellow blanket after the murder. As reported by Historic Mysteries, Justin was placed under hypnosis and questioned about the content of his dreams. It was Sharps mother, Sue, brother John and his friend Dana, laying in a pool of blood, bound with medical tape and appliance wire. Keddie28 reported Sharp immediately fled the cabin and ran to the neighbors for help. Sues ex-husband was in the military when they divorced, and the Navy gave her $250 a month to start her new life. The statement from Martys letter, What else do you want?, sounds like Marty is asking,In addition to what you already asked for, what more do you want me to do? Jamie ushered them out of the house through the bedroom window to protect them from the horrifying crime scene. Martys counselor at the Veterans Administration in Reno told police that Marty confessed to killing Sue and Tina but not the two boys. To Gamberg, it is clear that the DOJ and Thomas-run Sherriffs Dept. It's debated whether it was the murders themselves that led to less interest in renting in the once-busy area, or if it was the allegedly poor management of the cabins themselves that led to fewer people being willing to live there. Were they protecting their informant? The weapons included a steak knife that came from Sues kitchen. As reported by ABC10, John Boubede died in 1988, and Martin Smartt died in 2006. Furthermore, it suggests an answer as to why this case was handled so sloppily, remains unsolved, and is seemingly not a priority to the Sacramento DOJ. It was later confirmed that Martin was close with this Sheriff. Despite the multitude of evidence and a few suspects, no arrests took place. 5 Things to Know about the Keddie Cabin Murders and the Hunt for the Killers, 'People Magazine Investigates' : Inside Decades-Old Disappearances of 5 People Along the Snake River. The results of the analyses and tests are unknown. Rick and Greg claim they were asleep when the others were killed in the next room. That's the hope of Sheila Sharp, who discovered the bodies of her mother, brother and a friend at her family's cabin in Keddie, California, in 1981, in a mystery re-examined this past Monday in. Until 3 years to the day after the horrific murders a man collecting cans stumbled upon a human skull in Butte County CA. It was evident that Sue had put up a fight during the attack, as she had defensive wounds on her arms. They had died . 5 People Vanished Along the Snake River Beginning in 1979: Will Police Finally Catch a Serial Killer? [6] The house was much larger than the trailer, and had become available when Plumas County's then-sheriff, Sylvester Douglas Thomas, moved out. Tina was just 12 years old, John was 15, and Dana was 16. Investigation Police arrived at around 8:00 am and began their investigation of the murders. Where is the Body of the Legendary King Gorm of Denmark. Unsolved murders have a way of weighing on a community, the place forever haunted and the neighbors always left wondering. Note the sign on the front tree proclaims this was a home where a mom and her five children lived. It is unclear what evidence links Boubede to the mafia. The town tried to reinvent itself by becoming a recreational camping and hiking resort area. True Crime April 12, 1981. They happened upon John and his friend, Dana Hall Wingate (born February 8, 1964),[3] hitchhiking at the mouth of the canyon from Quincy to Keddie and picked them up, then driving about 6 miles (9.7km) away to Keddie. Near her bones in the woods, detectives also discovered a pair of jeans with a missing back pocket, a blue jacket, a blanket, and an empty surgical tape dispenser. They were still asleep and seemingly unaware of what happened. [30] However, in the 2008 documentary, Sheriff Doug Thomas said he had personally interviewed Martin and that he had passed a polygraph examination. After his interrogation, Marty Smartt left Keddie and went to live in Reno for a time. Gamberg thinks that at the same time, Sue was counseling Marilyn to leave Marty. "I believe there are two individuals that are alive and accessories after the fact,"Detective Mike Gamberg saidin an April 2021 interview with ABC10. But the memory of those murders has also stayed with the community and especially with the investigators who have re-opened the case of the 1981 attacks on Sue Sharp, her son Johnny, her daughter Tina, and family friend Dana Wingate. Since then, no arrests have been made, and the names have never been released to the public. Additionally, he said that Marilyn was his niece, which was also false. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Sheila would spend the night at the Seabolts. [29] He later criticized the quality of the initial investigation, saying: "You could take someone just coming out of the academy and they'd have done a better job. [24] According to Justin, John and Dana then entered the home and began heatedly arguing with the men. Nonetheless, it raises many questions. Even though Marilyn admitted in a 2008 documentary that she thought her husband his friend Bo was responsible, Sheriff Doug Thomas contradicted this and stated that Martin had successfully passed a polygraph test. Sue began renting out Cabin 28 at the Keddie Resort in 1980 when she relocated to Northern California after separating from her husband. The Keddie Murders is an unsolved 1981 American quadruple murder that took place in Keddie, a former resort town in the foothills of Northern California's Sierra Nevada mountains. [25], Rumors regarding the crimes being ritualistic or motivated by drug trafficking were dismissed by Plumas County Sheriff Doug Thomas, who stated in the week following the murders that no drug paraphernalia or illegal drugs were found in the home. Her fate remained unknown until her skeletal remains turned up in the woods three years later, as recounted Monday night in an episode of PEOPLEs new true-crime series on Investigation Discovery, People Magazine Investigates. until 2013 when the case was reopened with new investigators Plumas Sheriff Greg Hagwood and Special Investigator Mike Gamberg. People Magazine Investigates continues with new episodes that air Mondays (10 p.m. Historic Mysteries reports Marty's wife Marilyn found a bloody jacket in their basement, which she believed belonged to Tina. 109 min listen. On July 18, 1984, a lone gunman James Oliver Huberty entered a crowded McDonald's with a plan: "hunting for humans." He opened fire on the customers inside the fast-food chain, killing 21 and wounding 19 others. Sue had just divorced her husband and brought her children from Connecticut to Keddie in Northern California. Three of them were murdered that night, and one of the children remained missing until years later. Keddie is a small town in the Sierra Nevada mountains, located roughly halfway between Redding and Reno. His friend Dana was on the floor beside him on his stomach. When she opened the door, Sharp was horrified to find the bodies of her mother, brother John, and her brother's friend, Dana Wingate, covered in blood on the floor of the front room. Meanwhile, Sheriff Thomas had resigned from the investigation three months in and take a job instead at the Sacramento DOJ. [5] Upon arriving in California, she began renting a small trailer formerly occupied by her brother at the Claremont Trailer Village in Quincy. Tape secured the gag in place. The murders took place in cabin 28, during the late evening of April 11, 1981 and/or early morning of the 12th. Since his recruitment in 2013, he has made several new discoveries. [24] John Boubede, who allegedly had ties to organized crime in Chicago,[29] died there in 1988. Because she was a minor, the initial search for her involved the FBI, but, for some unknown reason, they quit investigating after about a month. On the night of April 11, 1981, four people were brutally murdered in Cabin 28 of the Keddie resort in Northern California. [21] Carla McMullen, a family acquaintance, later told detectives that Dana Wingate had recently stolen an unknown quantity of LSD from local drug dealers, though she was unable to provide proof of this claim. Findings confirmed that the weapons used on the victims heads were two different hammers and a BB gun in Sues case. The killers had escaped. Keddie Murders Revisited Part 1: New Evidence Discovered Links Living Suspect to Grisly Scene, November 15, 2019.Whelan, Micheal. "Keddie murders", Wikipedia "The Martin Smartt 'love letters'", kmik, The Great Zodiac Killer Hoax of 1986 . In 2016, Gamberg met with a counselor at the Reno Veterans Administration. This happened 41 years ago in Keddie, California. [6] Upon discovering the scene, Sheila rushed back to the Seabolts' house, whereupon Jamie Seabolt retrieved Rick, Greg, and Justin through the bedroom window. keddie murders survivorscumberland police department officers. Were convinced that there are a handful of people that fit those roles who are still alive.. Trampling through dead leaves, they stepped inside the perimeter of where the cabin once sat. The trio had been stabbed, bludgeoned, and strangled to death. The Sharp family had just moved in to cabin 28 the year before. The only thing authorities found that may reveal the identity of the killer, or killers, was DNA collected from a piece of medical tape used to bind the victims. More confounding is that the three youngest boys were not only untouched but allegedly unaware of the event, even though a woman and her boyfriend in the cabin next door awoke around 1:30 a.m. to what they described were muffled screams. [24] Plumas County Sheriff Sylvester Thomas, who presided over the case, later stated that Martin had provided "endless clues" in the case that seemed to "throw the suspicion away from him. On April 12, 1981, the victims, Glenna Sharp, (known as Sue), her son John (age 15), and his friend, Dana Wingate (age 17), were discovered in cabin 28 by Sue's 14-year-old daughter, Shelia, who was coming home from a sleepover. Although authorities believe they were both involved in the Keddie cabin murders, they think they may have had help. However, she forgot to bring the clothes she planned to wear to church. Marilyn later said in a 2008 documentary that she believed Marty was the perpetrator and that he had even confessed in writing to her. [27], On April 22, 1984, three years and eleven days after the murders, a bottle collector discovered the cranium portion of a human skull and part of a mandible at Camp Eighteen[17] near Feather Falls in neighboring Butte County,[28] roughly 100 miles (160km) from Keddie. Everyone loves a good mystery.But what about those good unsolved mysteries that don't have that satisfying ending like Scooby-Doo pulling off the mask of the culprit and are just downright spooky? The plastic piece that the police found in Cabin 28 matched up to a Daisy 880 BB gun. It is true that longtime cold cases can find warmth even after several decades. which Jamie had already done by entering through the cabin's back door to check for any survivors. Keddie28 reports she was attending business classes at the Feather River Community College, where she was purportedly a "good student" who worked hard to maintain high grades. Soon, PCSO squads would be on hand. Sheilas mother had been covered partially with a blanket though that had done little to hide her gruesome injuries. In 2016, Gamberg located a hammer believed to be one of the murder weapons in a dried-up pond in Keddie. He began hearing noises out in the living room and claimed to have seen Sue with two men. In July 1979, Glenna Susan "Sue" Sharp (ne Davis; born March 29, 1945 in Springfield, Massachusetts),[3] along with her five children, left her home in Connecticut after separating from her husband, James Sharp. Tips or information about the Keddie murders can be given anonymously by calling the Plumas County Sheriff's Office at 530-283-6360; the Secret Witness program at 775-322-4900; sending a text. After she saw the gruesome scene, Sheila ran back to the next-door cabin to get help. Sue's two younger sons, Rick and Greg, as well as their friend Justin Smartt, were also in the house but were unharmed. Watch the People Magazine Investigates After Show, available now on the new People/Entertainment Weekly Network (PEN). Accept Read More, The Disappearance of the Five Sodder Children, Brutal Murders on Germanys Hinterkaifeck Farm, Burke and Hare: Merchants in the Cadaver Market, John Paul Gettys Ransom: When Money Trumps Family. Inside The Unsolved Shooting Of Brooklyn's Hip-Hop King. A renewed investigation has caused the cold case to heat up, according to the People Magazine Investigates episode entitled Cabin 28: Horror in the Woods.. Investigators initially thought it may belong to a Native American person. Two suspects, Marty and Bo, died. [10], Justin gave conflicting stories of the evening, including that he had dreamed details of the murders, though he later claimed to have actually witnessed them. 2009-2021 Historic Mysteries. Some investigators who picked up the case when it reopened in 2013 tie the slayings into an even larger plot. It would take the police hours to realize that a fourth victim, Tina, was missing. Her brother, who would help her and the children start a new life, lived in Quincy, California, about 150 miles north of Sacramento. [24] Around 2:00 am on April 12, she stated she awoke to find the two burning an unknown item in the wood stove. Historic Mysteries is an Amazon Associate and earns from qualifying purchases. However, this turned out to be untrue. Interesting history topics are just a click away. Tina had briefly joined her sister at the neighbors before returning home to her mother, two younger brothers, and one of the neighbor boys, Justin Smartt. [19] Autopsies[21] determined that Sue and John died from the knife wounds and blunt-force trauma, and Dana died by asphyxiation. Then at 3:30 pm, the two teenagers headed out again.